Medicine
Sun May 31, 2020 10:46
Study: Wearing A Mask at Home Could Help Stop Coronavirus Spread Among Family Members
TEHRAN (FNA)- One of the few reliefs in our current pandemic is removing that mask when you arrive back home after a trip to the store. If you've got family there, however, a new study suggests you may want to keep it on.

The study, which was published in BMJ Global Health on Thursday, showed that wearing a mask at home was 79% effective at preventing the spread of the virus -- but only when family members started wearing masks before symptoms emerged in the first person infected. Cleaning the house frequently with bleach or disinfectants was almost equally effective at 77%.

"This study confirms the highest risk of household transmission being prior to symptom onset, but that precautionary [non-pharmaceutical interventions], such as mask use, disinfection and social distancing in households can prevent Covid-19 transmission during the pandemic," the study says.

In February, Chinese officials said most of the cluster cases they studied weren't coming from supermarkets or schools, but rather within families. Of the more than 1,000 cluster cases studied, 83% were identified as family clusters, according to Wu Zunyou, a virus expert with China's Center for Disease Control and Prevention.

While it was known that social distancing and mask wearing could prevent transmission of the disease in the community, there was little evidence to prove whether it was effective within families.

For the new study, researchers called 460 people from 124 families in Beijing who were living with an infected person and questioned them on their household hygiene and other behaviors during the pandemic.

Researchers found 41 out of the 124 families saw the virus being transmitted from the first infected person to other family members, totaling to 77 adults and children being infected. But the families who cleaned their homes with disinfectants daily, opened their windows and kept at least 1 meter (3 feet) apart were at lower risk of passing the virus, even in more crowded households.

Families who engaged in close daily contact, such as eating meals around a table or watching TV together were associated with an 18-fold increased risk. Daily close contact with a family member who was showing symptoms increased the risk for others, even if they started wearing masks at that point, according to the study.

The study is not without its critics

Some members of the scientific community who didn't participate in the study are recognizing its significance.

"This is an important paper because it comes at a time when -- as lockdown is eased -- the risk of a person entering the home who has become infected (e.g. whilst on public transport or in the workplace) but is unaware that this is so, is increasing," Professor Sally Bloomfield of London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine said in a statement.

Professor Trish Greenhalgh of University of Oxford mirrored her response, saying that the practice of wearing masks at home is "perhaps the most interesting as it's something that few people currently do in their own homes, especially when not symptomatic."

"Worryingly, whereas people who wore a mask before they became symptomatic with Covid-19 were significantly less likely to pass it on to others in the household, those who only started wearing the mask after they became symptomatic weren't able to protect their family members," Greenhalgh added.

But others have pointed to the study's limitations, including ones that the authors also recognized.

"Telephone interview has inherent limitations including recall bias," the study says. "The evaluation results of mask wearing were reliable, but we did not collect data on the concentration of disinfectant used by families."

Dr. Antonio Lazzarino at the University College London said that the study itself is not enough to make any official recommendations of any kind."This study is not robust science, as it has several limitations in the conception and in the statistical analysis," he said in a statement. "The main limitation is that it was designed at the family level, rather than at the individual level."

Lazzarino also pointed out that the study didn't make a distinction between whether the families were wearing N95 masks, surgical masks or basic cloth masks.

 

 

 

 

Bottom top
China Resolutely Opposes US Move on WeChat, TikTok

TEHRAN (FNA)- China's Ministry of Commerce (MOC) announced Saturday it is resolutely opposed to the US move to block downloads of WeChat and TikTok apps.
Maduro Calls Pompeo's 'War-Mongering' Tour A 'Failure'

TEHRAN (FNA)- Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro slammed US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo's visit to Latin American countries as a "war-mongering" tour that has failed.
Trump Calls China Bigger Problem Than Russia, Contradicting FBI

TEHRAN (FNA)- US President Donald Trump criticized on Friday the Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation Christopher Wray for overlooking China's threat to the integrity of upcoming Presidential election and focusing instead on Russia.
Coronavirus: Scientific Adviser Says UK Needs Urgent Restrictions to Avoid Thousands of Needless Deaths

TEHRAN (FNA)- Coronavirus restrictions should be imposed immediately on a national scale to avoid thousands of unnecessary deaths, a member of the government’s Sage scientific advisory group said.
US Congress Prepares to Approve Second-Largest Taiwan Arms Sale Valued at $7 Billion

TEHRAN (FNA)- US lawmakers are expected to soon approve a massive, new weapons sale to Taiwan, as the deal would provide the autonomous island not just with defensive weapons, but also with offensive capabilities in the form of long-range strike missiles and combat drones.
Global COVID-19 Death Toll Tops 950,000

TEHRAN (FNA)- The world hit a grim coronavirus milestone with more than 950,000 deaths, according to Johns Hopkins University data, as governments have been attempting to balance public health with economic health.
Protests in Al-Aqsa Against Normalization Agreements

TEHRAN (FNA)- Thousands of Palestinians responded to calls by Islamic and national activists to pray in the holy Al-Aqsa Mosque and participate in the demonstration against normalization following the Friday prayer.
US Bans WeChat, TikTok from App Stores, Threatens Shutdowns

TEHRAN (FNA)- The US Commerce Department said Friday it will ban Chinese-owned TikTok and WeChat from US app stores on Sunday and will bar the apps from accessing essential internet services in the US - a move that could effectively wreck the operation of both Chinese services for US users.
Doctor Dies of Heart Attack in West Bank After Israeli Forces Fire Stun Grenades Near Him

TEHRAN (FNA)- A dentist from Jenin, North of West Bank, died on Friday afternoon after Israeli occupation forces (IOF) fired stun grenades near him while he was returning from his work in Barta'a al-Sharqiya town, South of Jenin.
Spain Sees Record Daily Coronavirus Cases

TEHRAN (FNA)- Local officials in Madrid announced highly anticipated restrictions on Friday to limit contagion of the novel coronavirus as Spain shattered its all-time record for daily cases.
Early Voting Begins in Three US States

TEHRAN (FNA)- Lines formed at polling stations in three states on Friday, 46 days out from November 3, election day itself, as early voting began.
Kremlin: Too Much Absurdity in Navalny Case to Take Anyone’s Word on Trust

TEHRAN (FNA)- Kremlin Spokesman Dmitry Peskov said that there are too many absurd inconsistencies in the alleged poisoning of Russian blogger Alexey Navalny to take anyone's word for it.
UK Coronavirus Cases Rise by 4,322, Death Toll Increases by 27

TEHRAN (FNA)- The UK coronavirus death toll has risen by 27 and 4,322 COVID-19 cases were recorded in the past 24 hours, according to the latest figures from the government.
US Deploys Armored Vehicles to Syria, Steps Up Air Patrols After Dust-Up with Russian Forces

TEHRAN (FNA)- The Pentagon sent a number of armored vehicles, radar systems and additional troops to Syria in a show of force, bolstering the US military presence in the country following a run-in with Russian forces last month.
‘It Is Not Where We Want to Be’: WHO Says Coronavirus Killing About 50,000 People A Week

TEHRAN (FNA)- The World Health Organization (WHO) warned Friday that the coronavirus is “not going away”, noting that it’s still killing about 50,000 people a week.