Commentaries
Sat Jan 18, 2020 10:5
US Assassination of General Soleimani and International Law
TEHRAN (FNA)- On January 33 and under the direct order of President Donald Trump, the US army assassinated Lieutenant General Qassem Soleimani, commander of the Quds Force of the Islamic Revolution Guards Corps, in a drone attack at Baghdad International Airport.

Four days later, Iran successfully launched missiles at US military bases in Iraq in retaliation. Developments are still ongoing and it is time to analyze whether the US had the legal authority to execute such a deadly strike under international law and Charter of United Nations.

Seeking to defend this criminal action, the US government highlights two arguments: First, the IRGC has been designated as "a foreign terrorist organization" by the United States. As a result, Qassem Soleimani is "a terrorist mastermind". President Donald Trump goes even further to label him as "world's number one terrorist". For this reason, Trump claimed that "we take comfort in knowing his reign of terror is over". Second, according to Trump, Soleimani "was plotting imminent and sinister attacks on American diplomats and military personnel, but we caught him in the act and terminated him."

Though these explanations may be accepted by the Western audience at first glance, a careful assessment under international law and UN Charter will lead to an opposite answer:

First and foremost, it should be emphasized that the IRGC was designed as a terrorist organization by the US unilaterally instead of by the UN Security Council. Although there's a lack of universal agreement on the definition of terrorism or terrorist group under international law, two principles must be noticed:

- A particular state does not have the legal authority to declare a terrorist organization under international law.

- State entities, generally speaking, should not be placed on the list of terrorist organizations.

In the light of these two principles, Washington’s declaration that IRGC is a terrorist organization is hardly established and lawful. The IRGC is not a terrorist group at all according to the UN Security Council even though it had its assets frozen but it was lifted in 2016. More importantly, the IRGC is a branch of the Iranian Armed Forces, which means it is part of the Iranian government. In light of these, Washington’s first agreement is groundless and unlawful.

Secondly, Trump alleged the danger posed by Soleimani which prompted the US to conduct this strike was "imminent". In other words, the US has been arguing that the strike was out of some anticipatory self-defense. However, the assassination of Soleimani did not meet the elements of lawful self-defense under international law and UN Charter.

As a general principle, outside of an on-going armed conflict, international law prohibits the use of force, which is a peremptory norm codified in UN Charter. The only possible exception to the prohibition applicable in this case is self-defense. Nevertheless, the exception is limited. Some restrictions are provided in UN Charter Article 51 and others in the general principles of international law. It follows that international law does not permit the use of military force to respond to an alleged plan to an attack in the future including the "imminence". The "Imminence" is not included in UN Charter Article 51. The actual words are "if an armed attack occurs."

Even if an imminent attack could be resorted as justification to use force, the US failed to provide any rock-solid evidence to support its baseless claim. It still has no such evidence. On January 9, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo claimed, "There is no doubt that there were a series of imminent attacks that were being plotted by Qassem Soleimani". He then acknowledged that, "We don't know precisely when, and we don't know precisely where, but it was real." So the US argument that the strike was an act of anticipatory self-defense is indeed far from being persuasive and true.

Last but not the least, the US assassinated General Soleimani in Iraq rather than on its own territory, which encroached upon the sovereignty of Iraq, an independent sovereign state. Under the principle of equality of state sovereignty, the cornerstone of modern international law, the US was not permitted to use military force or execute its domestic law on Iraq’s territory. It had no consent.

In summation, the US went against international law and UN Charter. It also violated Iraq’s sovereignty by assassinating General Soleimani on Iraq’s soil - the man who helped Iraq and Syria to dislodge the terrorist group of ISIL when the whole world looked the other way. The US never had the consent from Iraq in the first place, which is why Iraqi Prime Minister Adel Abdul-Mahdi expressed his anger that the airstrike also killed an Iraqi official. This is also the reason why the Iraqi Parliament passed a resolution on January 5, calling for the government to expel US troops from the country in the wake of such a violation of their sovereignty, which by the way, was also condemned by the international community.

 

 

 

 

Bottom top
Global COVID-19 Death Toll Tops 950,000

TEHRAN (FNA)- The world hit a grim coronavirus milestone with more than 950,000 deaths, according to Johns Hopkins University data, as governments have been attempting to balance public health with economic health.
Protests in Al-Aqsa Against Normalization Agreements

TEHRAN (FNA)- Thousands of Palestinians responded to calls by Islamic and national activists to pray in the holy Al-Aqsa Mosque and participate in the demonstration against normalization following the Friday prayer.
US Bans WeChat, TikTok from App Stores, Threatens Shutdowns

TEHRAN (FNA)- The US Commerce Department said Friday it will ban Chinese-owned TikTok and WeChat from US app stores on Sunday and will bar the apps from accessing essential internet services in the US - a move that could effectively wreck the operation of both Chinese services for US users.
Doctor Dies of Heart Attack in West Bank After Israeli Forces Fire Stun Grenades Near Him

TEHRAN (FNA)- A dentist from Jenin, North of West Bank, died on Friday afternoon after Israeli occupation forces (IOF) fired stun grenades near him while he was returning from his work in Barta'a al-Sharqiya town, South of Jenin.
Spain Sees Record Daily Coronavirus Cases

TEHRAN (FNA)- Local officials in Madrid announced highly anticipated restrictions on Friday to limit contagion of the novel coronavirus as Spain shattered its all-time record for daily cases.
Early Voting Begins in Three US States

TEHRAN (FNA)- Lines formed at polling stations in three states on Friday, 46 days out from November 3, election day itself, as early voting began.
Kremlin: Too Much Absurdity in Navalny Case to Take Anyone’s Word on Trust

TEHRAN (FNA)- Kremlin Spokesman Dmitry Peskov said that there are too many absurd inconsistencies in the alleged poisoning of Russian blogger Alexey Navalny to take anyone's word for it.
UK Coronavirus Cases Rise by 4,322, Death Toll Increases by 27

TEHRAN (FNA)- The UK coronavirus death toll has risen by 27 and 4,322 COVID-19 cases were recorded in the past 24 hours, according to the latest figures from the government.
US Deploys Armored Vehicles to Syria, Steps Up Air Patrols After Dust-Up with Russian Forces

TEHRAN (FNA)- The Pentagon sent a number of armored vehicles, radar systems and additional troops to Syria in a show of force, bolstering the US military presence in the country following a run-in with Russian forces last month.
‘It Is Not Where We Want to Be’: WHO Says Coronavirus Killing About 50,000 People A Week

TEHRAN (FNA)- The World Health Organization (WHO) warned Friday that the coronavirus is “not going away”, noting that it’s still killing about 50,000 people a week.
Coronavirus Deaths on Rise in France

TEHRAN (FNA)- The numbers of deaths in France of people diagnosed with COVID-19 is trending upwards for the first time since the end of its lockdown, the public health agency said Friday, warning that all coronavirus indicators were now worsening.
Action Against Israeli Arms

TEHRAN (FNA)- Pro-Palestine activists continue to occupy the rooftop of arms component factory, UAV Engines who make drone parts for Israeli firm Elbit Systems. The protestors are calling for Elbit factories and their affiliates in the UK to be closed immediately. Elbit Systems is the chief supplier of drones to the Israeli Occupation Army with devastating consequences for Palestinian lives, as Amina Taylor explains. [VIDEO]
US: Oregon Wildfires Leave Trail of Devastation in Town of Gates

TEHRAN (FNA)- The wildfires in Oregon left a trail of devastation in their wake in the small town of Gates, as seen. The local primary school can be seen gutted by fire, while burnt out lorries and other fire damaged buildings can also be seen in the area. [VIDEO]
US: Anti Trump, BLM Protesters Demonstrate in Philadelphia

TEHRAN (FNA)- Everywhere US President Trump goes on the campaign trail he seems to bring BLM protest. In Philadelphia, the Trump supporters and his haters and BLM are facing off. “Go home racists” chants the Black Lives Matter/anti-fascist crowd to the Trump supporters outside the President’s town hall in Philadelphia. [PHOTOS]
Hurricane Sally: Deadly Storm Leaves 550,000 without Power in US

TEHRAN (FNA)- Tropical Storm Sally has left more than half a million Americans without power as its torrential rains and storm surges lashed the US Gulf coast. [PHOTOS]